8.d) 2-13-14 Proposal-Transition Area DevelopmentIF
Tiller Corporation
and its affiliated companies
TILLER Barton Sand & Gravel Co.
CORPORATION` Commercial Asphalt Co.
Barton Enterprises, Inc.
Corporate Office: Barton Industrial Sands, LLC
P.O. Box 1480
91
7200 Hemlock Lane, Suite 200 General: (763) 425-41
Maple Grove, Minnesota 55311-6840 Facsimile: (763) 4 3
3
Web: www.tillerc5illercorp.com
Proposed Revision to Reclamation Plan: Alternative Transition Area Development
1. Intent of Reclamation Plan Transition Area
The intent of developing a transition area at the Zavoral Site (Site), as indicated in the approved
Reclamation Plan, is to provide a transition area using existing, on-site trees along the established
woodland/forested edges and the newly planted prairie areas. The method selected for
development of this transition area relied primarily on the transplantation of suitable on-site trees
to areas along the existing woodland edge within Phase 1 Reclamation. The transplantation was to
occur after complete vegetation removal, including existing trees, followed by final grading with
engineered topsoil in an effort to minimize the spread and proliferation of invasive plant species
within transplanted transition areas.
2. Implementation of the Reclamation Plan, dated April 18, 2013
The Zavoral Tree Transplanting Results and the Annual Reclamation Report 2013, documents the
extensive efforts undertaken to establish transition areas through transplantation. The report
demonstrates that the method selected for the development of the transition areas between the
existing woodland and the planted prairie areas is not an effective means to accomplish the intent
of the Reclamation Plan. The work prescribed in the Reclamation Plan indicates a tree spade
between 65 inches to 90 inches will be used to transplant a minimum of 100 on-site white pine
trees into the proposed transition area within Phase 1 Reclamation. Due to the rocky/stony on-site
soils, including boulders and coarse material encountered throughout Phase 1 Reclamation,
transplanting the required trees proved to be unachievable. Suitable trees identified as transplant
candidates could not be successfully dug from the rocky and impenetrable parent soil.
Furthermore, the primary problem with transplantation was that due to rocky conditions, suitable
receiving holes for potential transplant trees could not be dug. A tremendous effort was made in an
attempt to develop the transition area using the implementation method selected in the
Reclamation Plan. These efforts were unsuccessful. After several dozen chosen transplant trees
were damaged beyond use as a result of unsuccessful transplant attempts the transplanting was
terminated.
3. Alternative Transition Area Development Plan
The Reclamation Plan recognizes the possibility that Site conditions experienced in the field may
require modifications to the Reclamation Plan. These modifications are termed adaptive
management techniques. Among other things, these techniques allow for changing the selected
implementation methods in order to accomplish the goals and intent of the Reclamation Plan.
February 13, 2014
Page 2 of 5
-IF
To accomplish development of the transition area,
an alternative plan has been developed. This plan
also utilizes on site trees and provides transition
areas by not clearing the perimeter areas which
were originally approved for clearing and to make
these areas into effective transition areas by
adaptive management. The number of on-site
trees that can be preserved with this approach far
outweighs the original number of on-site trees to
be transplanted. In portions of the Phase 1
Reclamation Area where there are no existing
transition trees, 16 inch to 24 inch tall white pine
seecuings are proposect for planting. i nis is the
Figure 1: Preserved transition area to the east of the size that can be installed by hand. Transplanting
orange fence. Image is facing north. of larger trees into the Phase 1 Reclamation Area is
not a viable method of developing a transition area. Therefore the following adaptive management
revisions are being proposed as methods to develop the transition area between the existing
woodland and planted prairie.
3.1. Proposed Revisions to Reclamation Plan:
3.1.1 Preserve the Existing Perimeter Areas as Transition Areas
Within the Phase 1 Reclamation Area, existing transition areas have been preserved that
were originally scheduled to be completely cleared of existing native and non-native
vegetation and planted as native prairie. Several hundred small to medium sized (8-20'
tall) mature trees have been preserved and occupy the area at moderate to high
densities. Tree species that were identified within the existing transition area that are
proposed to be preserved include: White Pine (Pinus strobus), Cottonwood (Populus
deltoides), Quaking Aspen (Populus tremuloides), Paper Birch (Betula papyrifera), Red Oak
(Quercus rubra), White Oak (Quercus alba), Box Elder (Acer negundo), American Elm
(Ulmus americana), and Black Cherry (Prunus serotina). Also identified in this area are
populations of invasive woody shrubs common buckthorn (Rhamnus cathartica), Siberian
elm (Zanthoxylem americanum) and weedy herbaceous species spotted knapweed
(Centaurea maculosa) sweet clover (Melilotus spp.).
3.1.2 Supplement Existing Transition Area with White Pine Seedlings
Within Phase 1 Reclamation where gaps occur in the existing transition areas along the
northern edge of Phase 1 Reclamation, 16 inch to 24 inch tall white pine bare root tree
seedlings will be installed by hand. The number of seedlings to be installed will be
dependent on the size of the gaps where supplementation is necessary to achieve the goals
and intent of the Reclamation Plan. The installation of the bare root seedlings will be
accomplished by creating a receiving hole for the bare root seedlings and planting the bare
root seedlings in a staggered and dispersed pattern to create a more natural transition
between the forest edge and the prairie plantings. Installation of the bare root seedlings
will take place in the early spring or fall, which are the optimum times to plant young trees.
The installation of each bare root seedling will be followed by mulching, watering, and
monitoring.
A qualified contractor will be responsible for installing bare root tree seedlings and will
water all newly installed seedlings within 2 hours of installation to assure proper moisture
levels and soil settling. The contractor will then return to the site within five days to add
February 13, 2014
Page 3 of 5
-IF.
any additional soil to the planting areas as needed to fill any voids left from soil settling. If
necessary, bare root seedlings will be repositioned.
Bare root tree seedlings installed as described above will be monitored throughout the first
two growing seasons to assure appropriate soil moisture levels are maintained. When soil
moisture levels are low, supplemental watering will occur through a surface watering
method brought on-site with a transportable watering tank. During dry periods, tree
seedlings will be watered up to one time per week. When watering, mulch will be pulled
back and the area around the roots thoroughly soaked. When watering is complete mulch
will be replaced.
3.1.3 Vegetation Management of Transition Area
Annual Maintenance of Transition Area
In the preserved transition area described above in 3.1.1, rigorous reclamation and
management activities will be completed in an effort to develop a high quality, natural
forest/woodland transition zone. To minimize the spread and proliferation of invasive
plant species, in the late fall, non-native, invasive and overly aggressive woody shrubs
including common buckthorn and Siberian elm will be cleared from the preserved areas.
Remaining stumps will be treated with an appropriate herbicide to prevent resprout. At
the start of the following growing season, the herbaceous vegetation will be evaluated by
the project ecologists. Non-native, invasive or overly aggressive herbaceous species
including spotted knapweed and sweet clover will be selectively treated with herbicide in a
sensitive and targeted manner. Following removal of non-native herbaceous species in the
understory, areas of exposed soil (bare areas) will be seeded with the approved native
prairie seed mix using a hand broadcast method at a rate of at least 50 seeds per square
foot. When available, seed utilized during this portion of the project will be local ecotype.
Following initial restoration activities, the site will be continually and actively managed for
a minimum of five years. Follow-up maintenance activities will include removal and
treatment of any non-native, invasive and overly aggressive woody species, spot treatment
of any non-native, invasive and overly aggressive herbaceous species and reseeding of bare
areas as needed to meet performance goals described below.
3.1.4 Performance Monitoring of Transition Area
Annual Monitoring
Consistent with the Reclamation Plan, performance monitoring will take place. The
preserved transition area as described above in 3.1.1 will be monitored annually following
management and maintenance activities. Management and maintenance activities will be
adjusted to assure that the following performance goals are met for the site as per the CUP,
Condition #63:
Areal vegetative coverage of at least 90% within 3 years post seed installation;
Non-native, invasive or overlay aggressive woody and herbaceous species will
account for no more than 20% areal cover at the end of the 5t" growing season, post
seed installation;
At least 50% of the species seeded or plugged into the area will be present within
the reclamation area within five years of initial restoration activities;
February 13, 2014
Page 4 of 5
-IF
Bare root tree seedlings installed as described above in 3.1.2 will also be monitored on an
annual basis to assure the following performance standards are met:
• Newly installed bare root tree seedlings will be required to meet a survival rate of at
least 80%, survival rates of less than 80% will require replacement;
Trees that were transplanted as described above in section 2 will be monitored on an
annual basis to assure the following performance goals are met as per the CUP, Condition
#65:
Transplanted trees will meet a survival rate of at least 80%. If survival rates are less
than 80%, replacement will be required;
If necessary, replacement tree species will be selected in consultation with the City
of Scandia;
February 13, 2014
Page 5 of 5
Aerial Imagery of Phase 1 Reclamation
Google Earth Imagery Date: September 15, 2013
Preserved Transition Area within Phase 1 Reclamation and
Preserved Transition Area within Phase 3 Reclamation and
located in the St. Croix Scenic Easement. Image is facing located in the St. Croix Scenic Easement. Image is facing
north. northeast.
Preserved Transition Area within Phase 1 Reclamation and
located in the City's River District. Image is facing north.
Preserved Transition Area within Phase 1 Reclamation and
located in the City's River District. Image is facing east.