7.b iv. Presentation to the City Council on the Comprehensive PlanCity Council
May 15, 2018
What is a
Comprehensive
Plan?
A framework and vision for
the next 20-30 years in the
city’s future
Identifies goals & policies for
the physical development of
the City
Manages anticipated growth
Guides ALL stakeholders in
making land use decisions
Provides a legal basis for
zoning & other ordinances
2
Chapters
Introduction
Vision, goals,
background
Land Use
Community
designation
Existing and future
land use
Natural Resources
Aggregate
resources,
significant areas
Resilience
Solar
Economic
Competitiveness
Description
Housing
Existing and
projected needs
Parks & Trails
Existing and
proposed
Transportation
Existing system
Transit, freight,
aviation
Water Resources
Wastewater
Surface Water
Water Supply
Implementation
Action Plan
Process
Public Engagement
Website
(https://clients.bolton-menk.com/scandia/)
2 Pop-Up Meetings
3 Focus Groups
Youth
Business/Agricultural
55+
Steering Committee
3 Meetings
Community Survey
City Council Workshop
Public Open House
Planning Commission Discussions
January –April, 2018
Planning Commission Public Hearing
May 1, 2015
Common
Themes
Strengths:
Rural, open space, history
Weaknesses:
Internet service, transportation,
aging population and lack of younger
families
Common
Themes
Priorities for the Future
Agricultural Preservation
Residential & Commercial
Growth
Walking/Biking/Horseback
Riding Trails
Life Stage Housing
What’s New?
Community
Designation
Proposed Future Land Use Map
Revised after Planning Commission Hearing
Community
Designation
Diversified Rural
Protecting land for
rural lifestyles and
long-term urbanization
Home to a variety of
farm and non-farm
land uses.
Large areas of high-
quality natural
resources
Large portions of
community contain
prime agricultural soils
Rural Center
Serve the rural area as
small town centers of
commerce
Surrounded by
agricultural lands
Generally have a mix of
housing densities, and
strong commercial
service districts in a
traditional downtown
district
May have wastewater
treatment services
Definition
Community
Designation
Impact
Overall Density Expectations
New Growth, Development and Redevelopment
Designation Density
Diversified Rural 4 units/40 acres maximum
Rural Center 3-5 units per acre minimum
Density is an average for all residential
development in the City
This allows flexibility to have a mix of higher and
lower density ranges
The Comprehensive Plan must provide available
land to meet forecasted growth at expected
densities
Density expectations apply to NEW growth,
development or redevelopment
Existing Net Residential Density in Scandia is 3.6
units/40 acres (Table II-H)
Plan and Zoning Ordinance recognize increased
density may not occur without municipal and/or
community sewer
Developable LandDevelopment Constraints
Developable Land
Proposed Future Land Use Map
Revised after Planning Commission Hearing
Planned
Land Use
Land Use Gross Acres Percentage
Agricultural Core 7,300 28.7%
General Rural 9,837 38.7%
Mining 443 1.7%
Rural Commercial 75 0.3%
St. Croix River District 760 3.0%
Village Neighborhood 1,435 5.6%
Village Mixed Use 313 1.2%
Park,Recreational,
Protected Area 1,887 7.4%
Open Water 3,302 13.0%
Railway 72 0.3%
Total 25,423 100%
Forecasts
The Land Use Plan must provide available land to
meet forecasted growth
Forecasts
2010 2015 2020 2030 2040
Population 3,934 3,896 4,260 4,630 4,950
Households 1,498 1,518 1,700 1,910 2,100
Employment 519 540 620 690 730
Source: Metropolitan Council
Density Calculations
Residential Density Calculations
Land Use Density
(un/ac)
Desired
Distribution
Number
of Units
Acres
Needed
Current
Developable
Acres
Agricultural Core 4/40 5%29 291 6,903
General Rural 4/40 20%116 1,164 6,524
St. Croix River Corridor 4/40 5%29 291 439
Village Neighborhood ½.5 65%378 946 970
Village Mixed Use ½.5 5%29 73 156
Total 100%581 2,765 14,182
Commercial/Industrial Density Calculations
Land Use/Zoning
Density
(Jobs/Acre)Desired
Distribution
Number
of Jobs
Acres Needed Current
Developable
AcresMinMaxMinMax
Village Mixed Use 14 62.4 75%143 2.3 10.2 139
Rural Commercial 11.4 50.7 25%48 0.9 4.2 49
Total 100%190 3.2 14.3 205
Staging Plan
Table II-O –Staging of Future Land Use Units/Jobs/Acres
Outside Urban
Service Area
Average Density
Range Housing
Existing
Developable
(2015)
2020 2030 2040
Residential Units/Acre Acres Units Acres Units Acres Units Acres
Agricultural Core 0.1 6,093 9 90 10 100 10 100
General Rural 0.1 6,524 39 388 39 388 39 388
St. Croix River
Corridor Area 0.1 439 9 90 11 110 10 100
Village Mixed Use 0.4 156 5 13 12 30 12 30
Village Neighborhood 0.4 970 120 300 132 330 126 315
Non-Residential Estimated
Employment/Acre
Developable
Acres Jobs Acres Jobs Acres Jobs Acres
Village Mixed Use 14 62.4 125 60 4.3 52 3.7 30 2.14
Rural Commercial 11.4 50.7 32 20 1.8 18 1.6 10 0.9
Required by the Met Council
Based on forecasted growth
Assumes development will occur in each 10-year increment
Example calculation:
5% of growth anticipated in Agricultural Core (582 * 5% = 29
units)
29 units/3 = 9.7 units per 10-year increment
9 units * 0.1 units/acre = 90 acres developed in 1st 10-year
increment
New
Chapters
Natural Resources
Aggregate resources
Regionally significant areas
Resilience
Solar protection
GreenStep Cities program
Economic Competitiveness
Goals
Historical employment
Housing
408
851 1,060 1,294 1,498 1,518 1,700 1,910 2,100
1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2016 2020 2030 2040
Households Projections
Households
Forecasts
Source: Metropolitan Council
14%
25%
15%
46%
23%20%
9%13%
APARTMENTS TOWNHOMES RENTAL SINGLE
FAMILY HOMES
SENIOR/ASSISTED
LIVING
CLUSTER/OPEN
SPACE
MULTI-
GENERATIONAL
ADU OTHER
Housing Gaps
Source: 2017 Comprehensive Plan Community Survey
Housing
Implementation
Plan
Housing
Goal/Need Available Tool Opportunity and Sequence of Use Potential Partners
Multi-
Generational
Community
Living
Start-Up Loan Program Assist first-time homebuyers with
purchase and down payment assistance Minnesota Housing
Home Improvement
Loans
Assist homeowners in financing home
maintenance projects
Washington County
CDA, Minnesota
Housing
ADU Ordinance
Continue to support ordinances permitting
the construction of accessory dwelling
units or guest homes
Property Owners
Program or Framework
Work with groups and stakeholders to
develop guiding principles, frameworks,
and action plans to consider and
incorporate the needs of older residents
into development decisions
Senior advocacy
groups or networks,
residents
Maintaining
Existing
Housing Units
Home Improvement
Loans
Assist homeowners in financing home
maintenance projects
Washington County
CDA, Minnesota
Housing
Subsurface Sewage
Treatment System
Repair Grant/Loan
Assist homeowners with noncompliant
subsurface sewage treatment systems Washington County
New Housing
Construction
Tax Increment
Financing
Encourage development of new housing
units, redevelopment and/or infrastructure
improvements through the creation of a
TIF district
Washington County
CDA
GROW Fund
Provide gap financing for new or
redevelopment projects affordable to
owner or renter households at or below
60% AMI
Washington County
HRA
Other City Ordinances
Review ordinances to identify potential
opportunities for cluster development and
flexible development Planning
Commission and
City CouncilReview ordinances to identify any
regulations that inhibit housing priorities.
Regional Trail
Considerations
Local Parks
Transportation
Water
Resources
Wastewater
Identifies limitations of existing
public and private systems
Identifies potential expansion
on municipal sewer
Surface Water
Summarizes Local Surface
Water Management Plan
Water Supply
Summarizes local water supply
Implementation
Official Controls
Zoning and Subdivision
Ordinances
CIP
Amendment Procedure
Action Plan Worksheets
Specific action steps by
chapter and goal
Next Steps
Submit plan for adjacent/affected
community review
Allow 6 months to submit comments
Address any comments received
City Council adopts resolution
authorizing submittal of plan to the
Metropolitan Council
Metro Council has 120 days to review and
approve
City must address any comments
Following approval, begin review of
Zoning Ordinance and Subdivision
Ordinance to ensure compliance with
Comprehensive Plan
Thank you!
Questions /
Comments
Jane Kansier, AICP
Janeka@Bolton-menk.com
952-890-0509