3. Gravel Road Surface TreatmentsJkill
�I
:Lit. �5:;' :t•. I. �"`.
September 2, 2015
GRAVEL ROAD - ISSUES
Loose surface
aggregates
Pot holes
Frost Boils
Wash Boarding
Snow Plow Damage
Dug up Roads
Plow berms
Lose of Crown
Dust
�J
SCANDIA
OPTIONS
Maintain Existing Gravel
Bituminous Pavement - Shape the existing gravel &
pave 4" overlay.
Improved gravel road - Prime Coat and Chip Seal
SCANDIA
W
CHIP SEAL - PROCESS
1. Perform infrastructure replacement, if necessary. (Culverts)
2. Repair any soft spots or frost boils.
3. Grade the existing gravel to the provide a uniform section and
surface. Provide a 4% crown and positive drainage to the
ditches.
4. Add gravel where necessary to provide a solid base.
5. Compact the road to 100% density.
6. Apply primer coat of emulsion and allow to cure.
7. Apply emulsion and chip seal aggregate.
8. If desired, a second layer of emulsion and aggregate can be
applied.
SCANDIA
CHIP SEAL - CUNSIDERATIQNS
• Reduces dust/ mud as it is a water -proof membrane surface.
• Intended for lower volume roads <300 ADT
Provides a smooth driving surface. (w/adequate base and
proper preparation work)
Erosion of the surface and loss of aggregates is eliminated.
Can be damaged as it is a thin flexible mat of oil and rock, but
can be repaired.
Repairs are significantly less in cost than a bituminous or
concrete surface and can easily be performed.
• Requires a new chip seal every 5-7 yrs.
• Surface can be plowed and salted during winter
similar to a bituminous surface.
SCANDIA
CHIP SEAL - CUNSIDERATIQNS
Chip sealing does not provide strength to the road like a
bituminous application. Road is only as strong as the
gravel base.
Road proposed for chip seal should be monitored for soft spots
and frost heaves during the freeze thaw cycle.
Construction should occur after frost is out of the ground and
before Sept. 1
SCANDIA
CASE STUDY - SILITER CREEK TOWNSHIP IN 2013
4 miles of gravel roads were improved. Initially designed to
chip seal with a fog seal
Changed to double chip seal during construction.
Performed two other test sections
700' of Chip Seal with Fog Seal (original design)
700' of Chip Seal, Sand Seal with Fog Seal
First month had some incidents that tore through the mat.
Self Propelled Agricultural Sprayer tore through shoulder
Dual wheeled truck tore through while turning around in the middle
of the road
Broom brush burned through mat.
Tractor break skid at an intersection tore mat.
SCANDIA
REPAIRS
The repair process is simple, We bought a couple pails offoundation coating from
Menards. Glean and pack outthe damaged area. Pour in some foundation coating oil.
Add the FA-3A chips and pack level. {5ee picsj
Photos/Information from: Chip Seal over Gravel Road Project
Report in Silver Creek Township dated July 2013
r � �
Photos from: Chip Seal over Gravel Road
Project Report in Silver Creek Township dated
July 2013
SCANDIA
CASE STUDY -RESULTS
■ Smooth Ride
• Eliminated muddy conditions
• Eliminated dusty conditions
• Bituminous like surface performance
■ Residents are happy
SCANDIA
DOUBLE CHIP SEAL PROJECTS
PERFORMED BY FARHNER ASPHALT
City/Town A .--a is Location
Town of Clam Falls 3401h Ave, Fredric WI
(W. from 1151h St.)
280th Street
Town of Farmington (South from 30th Ave)
Town of Hayward Indian Lake Rd
Town of Round Lake Various Streets
City of Shell Lake South Shore Drive
1 Mile 2013
3.5 Miles 2014
2 Miles 2012
Unknown 2012
0.75 Mile 2011
SCANDIA
1*--Z/'i,< ®
185T" STREET -TEST HOLES
SCANDIA
185TH STREET N-TEST HOLES
J li14940
I L I
14939
IC-- \�I I
12" CLASS 5 '
-
I
-
I I I I III 1 I
18989 18901
I I I I
---------------------I -------------
Ir V i I I ', !I
I I I I I @4
I
I�II Q 18889 6530 LF �I
----------- - - - - - - - - z
III T-_________ �_�z------------------- ------ __-___T-__r__-_-_-----+----__------________-.-_--_----___----------+_...__..___.....-..____.._._____+__
a 18880
LD I / 10" CLASS 5 + 5" ROCKY CLAYS
14740 I f d fi
III-------18655 ---- -- laoao j 4--- lsoao CITY LIMIT
H r 18625 Ji---- i I'S� I, „
I, Q � i I
O 16 "+ CLASS 5 14018 12" CLASS i 7i it 16" CLASS
��-1fi"+CLASS $--=--'-r- -- - — — --- � - --.-- - —,r----------------- ---_ _ _—�--I---
rj 185TH ST N I,
13961 N 15 " CLASS 5 I
Ili 14025 19 li li Q 14" CLASS 5 I i;
it ',I li 14661 w 15072 i li
r Q I 19
I O II i I U ILPI
-------- --- -L— -- —
I
I
18081 15261�� #
I I I lil 15097 ---------
s�,IE
I I I �1
Irpez 'I
I
�X,F V r V 'ten B C7 LTC3 N P M E N K� I N C CITY OF SCMARINE RAIL EST HG
1I dVdV G ns Ilf g E gf r s & Surveyors 185TH ST&E)l➢MARINE TRAIL-TEiT HOLES
snuG mx rvxu�wmn x
FIGURE NG.1
185TH STREET -.
USGS SOILS IN4ENTORY
x
�
a
a
3
FIL
t-
49
Feet
Source:
1 507 1 Somewhat poorlydrained I B fine -silty over sandy or sandy -skeletal
SCANDIA
COST ESTIMATE -
DOUBLE CHIP SEAL
ENGINEER'S ESTIMATE
I rnproved Gravel Road - 1 85th St - Dciubl e Chip Seal
City of Scandia, Minnesota
6530 FT Total Length (1.24 mi)
26 FT Average Width
ITEM
NO.
ITEM
Part I - Double Chip Semi!
1
MoNlization
2
Traffic Control
3
Subgrade Excavatiofl
4
SuNrade Preparation
5
Aggregale Raw, Class -5
18
Penelraliriq Emulsion Primer
7
CRS-2P Emulsion
a
FA-M Trap Rork
Subtotal Part 1-Double Chip Seall;
Part 2- Ditching and Culverts
9
Clear and Grub
10
Dilch Grading
11
Select Topsoil Borrow
12
Erosion Control
13
RCP Culvert
14
RCP Flared End Soclion
Subtotal Part 2- Ditching and Culverts
DATE: 8),al"2017,
OTY UNIT UNFT PRICE TOTAL
I LS
$8.000.00
$a.000.00
I LS
$3,500.00
$3,500.00
950 CY
$12.00
$11,400.00
20760 SY
$1.00
$20.760.00
4170 TN
$10,00
S41,700.00
74300 gal
$3.01)
$22,800.00
13300 gal
S101)
$39,900.00
400 TNS
$50.01)
$20,000.00
$1 051016om
I LS
$5,004.00
$5,000,00
7 STA
$5.00D.00
$35.000.00
60 CY
$17.00
1 LS
$7.51)D.00
$7,500.00
350 LF
$20.01)
$7.00100
14 EA
$800.00
$11,200.00
$66.720,00
suhtotaL $234,7813.00
20% Contingency, Legal, Administrative, Engineering, Permits- Malenals Testing; W4 960.00
Total Ertimaled Product Cost - Improved Gravo Road- 185th St - Double Chip Baal: S281,74DAI)
SCANDIA
COST ESTIMATE -
SHAPE AND PAVE
ENGINEER'S ES TIMATE
Gravel Road Paving -185th St- Shape anti Pa.�
City of Scandia, Minnesota
DATE: 021,+201 r.
653D FT Taal Length = 1.24 mi
24 FT Average Width
ITEM
No.
ITEM
QTY UNIT
UNIT P'RICF
TOTAL
Part t - S11ape and Pain
1
Mobilizamn
1 LS
$15.000.00
$15,000.00
2
Traffio Con(ml
1 LS
$3,50o.00
$3,500.00
3
Subgrade Excavation
860 t:Y
$12.00
$1101560,00
4
Sut+grade Preparatlon
19160 5Y
$1.00
$1J,16t5.S70
5
Agigregiale Base, Class 5
4910 TN
$10.00
$411,1(10.00
6
Bituminous Base Course MWure
2820 TN
56$,00
$191,760.00
7
Slluminous Wearing Course Midurs
1690 TN
$68.00
$112,880.00
S
Bituminous Tack Coat
980 GAL
$4.00
$3,840.013
9
Wearing Course Mixture- CriuewayApron
50 TN
$85.00
$4,250.00
10
Sawing 9ihiminous Pavement
270 LF
$6.00
$1,620.00
11
Aggregate Shouldering, Class 2
1060 TN
$24.00
$25,440.00
12
Signing and Stripling
t LS
$7,500100 $7,500.00
SubtotaI (Part t- Shape and Pave,
$444.61040
Fart 2- Ditching and Culverts
13
Clear and Grub
t LS
$51000. ]0
$5,000,00
14
Ditch GradiN
7 STA
$5,000.00
$35,DDO.00
15
Seled Topsc> l Borrow
60 CY
i$17.00
$1,020,0C
16
Eroslon Control
1 LS
$7,500.00
$7,500,00
17
RCP Culvert
350 LF
$20.00
$7,000.00
18
RCP Flared End Section
14 EA
$000,00
$111200.0r
Subtotal Part 2 - ®itehilng and Culverts
$661720.00
5ubbatal: $s11,330,Uu
20% Contingancr , tegal, Adminlstram, Eilg incuring. Permits, Materials Testing: $102,274.4C
Total Estimated Project Cost - Improved Grave Road- 185th St - Bauble Chip Seal: $613,600.00
SCANDIA
COST
Double Chip Seal $7.20 $14.95
Shape and Pave $23.85 $35.20
Gravel Road Annual Maintenance Savings
Routine Grading
Addition of gravel
Dust Control Measures (chloride application)
SCANDIA